Comment on: Laparoscopic access in the treatment of palpable cryptorchidism (review)

In issue #1 of volume 28 (2024) of the "Russian Journal of Pediatric Surgery" journal, an international team of authors published the scientific review "Laparoscopic access in the treatment of palpable cryptorchidism (review)" (DOI: https://doi.org/10.17816/ps667). The article analyzed international publications with the results of using laparoscopic access for orchiopexy of palpable testicles. Unfortunately, in all the articles mentioned in the review the follow-up period was 12–18 months. In addition, there is no assessment of gonads state before descending in the analysed articles. It seems that a mechanistic approach was chosen: they used laparoscopic access, mobilised the testis, performed orchiopexy, made sure that there was no atrophy or retention, and assessed the result as positive. This is not sufficient to analyse and objectively evaluate the proposed method in a statistically valid manner. When choosing an orchiopexy method, it is necessary to be guided by reliable long-term results and try not to contrast traditional orchiopexy methods with laparoscopic methods.